Letter To The Editor: Build Shipyards On River System To Meet Demand
Earlier this month, voters told Washington to stop spending money that doesn’t show up in people’s lives, flipping Senate seats in Iowa and Ohio and handing Congress to Democrats. As Congress returns to finish the defense bill, that message should shape how America rebuilds its shipbuilding capacity.
No one disputes the need. China builds more than half the world’s commercial ships; America builds well under 1 percent. Three-quarters of the Ready Reserve Force, our crisis sealift fleet, are past their service lives. Submarine production runs at about half the Navy’s target. The commercial collapse feeds the military one. The same yards and trades now struggle to meet Navy targets. The volume and repetition of standardized commercial work are what keep skills and capacity warm between defense programs.
So far, Washington has gone big in a few places: a Puget Sound drydock reportedly priced near $30 billion and a fifth public Navy shipyard plan due by mid-December. Nuclear submarines do need nuclear-capable yards, but pouring more money behind fewer fences repeats the model that created the backlog.
There is a better option, and it runs through the middle of the country.
America’s Fourth Coast is the 12,000-mile Ohio and Mississippi river system. It reaches 21 states, carries over 500 million tons of freight a year and runs past world-class steel mills: Nucor in Kentucky, Cleveland-Cliffs in Indiana, Big River Steel in Arkansas. Marine fabricators line its banks, and NASA has floated rocket stages down it for decades. Below Cairo, Ill., there isn’t a single lock before the Gulf.
Our proposal, FLOW (Fabrication Leveraging Our Waterways), is simple. Build standardized modules (hull blocks, machinery skids, deckhouses) at several inland sites at once, sized for river locks. Then float them to Gulf Coast yards for assembly. They can serve sealift ships, auxiliaries and commercial tankers, bulkers, RoRo vessels and dredges. The goal isn’t one ship faster at one yard. It is more ships under construction at once, nationwide.
We have done this before. Answering Roosevelt’s call for an Arsenal of Democracy, Henry J. Kaiser multiplied yards, standardized one design and prefabricated sections off site. He cut Liberty Ship build times from months to weeks and produced nearly 1,500 vessels. Evansville, Ind., alone built more than 160 tank landing ships that floated down these rivers to war. What is new is the geography and the urgency.
Fiscal conservatives should like this, and after earlier this month, so should everyone in Washington. It starts with a small demonstrator, not a megaproject. States and private investors pay in first. Fabricators compete against a common standard instead of waiting in a sole-source queue. Performance is published quarterly, and a site that misses its targets loses expansion funding automatically. We estimate the 10-year federal share at a fraction of one coastal drydock. Commercial demand also draws private capital that defense work alone cannot.
The limits are real: shallow rivers, low bridges, floods and droughts. Inland yards won’t build carriers or nuclear submarines, but they can take on the steel-heavy, repeatable work clogging coastal yards, freeing those yards for what only they can do.
The politics are favorable. Sens. Mark Kelly, a Democrat, and Todd Young, a Republican, wrote the SHIPS for America Act, and the House added its provisions to the defense bill without objection. Likely host communities like Evansville, Paducah, Memphis and Osceola just told both parties they’re tired of waiting for an economy that works for them.
In the lame-duck conference, Congress should keep the SHIPS provisions and add a narrow, performance-based Ohio and Mississippi demonstrator. The Pentagon should consider distributed inland fabrication in its fifth-yard plan. And the Maritime Administration, Navy and Army Corps of Engineers should pick the pilot’s first vessels within six months.
Eighty years ago, America out-built the world by treating the whole country as its shipyard. We can again. The Fourth Coast is not a metaphor. It is a manufacturing strategy.
J. Sebastian Smelko, Phil Wilzbacher and Ken Eriksen
J. Sebastian Smelko is a partner at Ice Miller LLP in Indianapolis and former general counsel of the Ports of Indiana. Phil Wilzbacher, owner of Wilzbacher Consulting Services, served 19 years with the Ports of Indiana, including as port director at Mount Vernon. Ken A. Eriksen is managing member of Polaris Analytics and Consulting.


